Cookie Sheets
Looking for the perfect cookie sheet to whip up your favorite treats? Look no further! In this article, we’ll guide you through a roundup of the top cookie sheets on the market, helping you find the one that’s just right for you. From non-stick surfaces to even heating, we’ve got all the details you need to make an informed decision. So sit back, relax, and get ready to bake some delicious cookies!
The Top 15 Best Cookie Sheets
- The Non-Stick Turquoise Cookie Sheet by GreenLife — The GreenLife Ceramic Non-Stick Cookie Sheet in Turquoise offers easy cleaning and a non-stick surface, but may require more careful handling due to its non-durable nature.
- Farberware Insulated Nonstick Jumbo Cookie Sheet — This Farberware Insulated Nonstick Jumbo Cookie Sheet, featuring double layer pans and insulated airflow, guarantees even baking for large quantities of cookies. It boasts a sturdy, non-stick design for a hassle-free cleaning experience after every use.
- Doughmakers: Perfect for All Your Cookie Creations — Doughmakers Grand Cookie Sheet: A commercial-grade, 18-gauge aluminum cookie sheet with a patented pebble pattern that ensures even baking, quick release, and non-stick properties, making it a popular choice among professional bakers.
- Sturdy Non-Stick Cookie Sheet with Large Capacity — Experience effortless baking with the Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Nonstick Baking Sheet, featuring heavy gauge aluminized steel construction, a non-stick interior and exterior, and a stylish design for increased capacity and baking versatility.
- Little Sheet Mustard Cookie Sheet — Little Sheet Mustard: Your petite, multi-colored, non-toxic baking companion, safe for oven and dishwasher use.
- Doughmakers Premium Biscuit Sheet for Perfect Cookies — Experience the perfect blend of professional durability, natural non-stick properties, and even heat distribution with the Doughmakers biscuit sheet, designed for effortless and healthier baking.
- GRIDMANN 15" x 21" Commercial Grade Aluminum Cookie Sheets (3 Quarter Sheets — 6 Pans) — Unleash your culinary prowess with the GRIDMANN 15" x 21" Commercial Grade Aluminum Cookie Sheet Baking Tray Pan, equipped with 6 pans for seamless preparation of generous portions of food.
- Wilton Bake It Better Nonstick Steel Cookie Sheet (10x15 in.) — Safe for Metal Tools, Dishwasher-Safe — Impress your guests with perfectly baked treats on the Wilton Bake It Better Steel Cookie Sheet, featuring a non-stick coating and large grip handles for safe and easy use.
- Stainless Steel Cookie Baking Sheet for Delicious Treats — Experience versatile and easy-to-clean baking with the Norpro Stainless Steel Cookie Baking Sheet, perfect for cookies, pastries, and more!
- Stackable Nonstick Baking Sheet Set by JoyTable — Delight your taste buds with the Joytable Baking Sheet Set, stackable and sturdy with non-stick quality, making it the perfect addition to your baking essentials.
- Perfect Results Non-Stick Cookie Sheets Set — Cook up perfect batches of cookies with Wilton’s Premium Non-Stick Cookie Baking Sheets Set, featuring easy-to-handle edges and superior non-stick performance.
- Non-Stick Cookie Sheet by Cuisinox — Perfect for Baking — The Cuisinox Non-Stick Cookie Sheet is a must-have for all cookie enthusiasts, featuring an easy-to-clean non-stick coating and long-lasting durability, while also boasting a visually appealing design.
- Farberware Nonstick Cookie Sheet Set — This 3-piece Farberware Nonstick Cookie Pan Set with Grey color boasts heavy-duty construction, even heating, and nonstick surface for seamless food release and quick cleanup.
- Lekue Non-Spill Baking Sheet — Perfect for Cookies and Goodies — Prepare delicious and healthy baked goods effortlessly with Lekue’s flexible, non-stick non-spill baking sheet, perfect for all oven trays and guaranteeing a clean oven every time.
- Stainless Steel Cookie Sheet with Cooling Rack for Even Baking and Easy Cleanup — Experience premium baking with the TeamFar Baking Sheet with Rack Set, featuring non-toxic, rust-free stainless steel and a sleek design suitable for a range of daily baking needs.
As an Amazon Affiliate™, I earn through qualifying purchases at no cost to you!
Reviews
The Non-Stick Turquoise Cookie Sheet by GreenLife
I recently added the GreenLife Turquoise Cookie Sheet to my collection, and it has been a game-changer in my kitchen. The vivid turquoise color is definitely eye-catching and adds a pop of color to my otherwise monotonous counter. Not only does it look great, but it boasts some impressive functionality.
The non-stick ceramic coating is made without PFAS or PFOA, which made me feel much more comfortable cooking on it. It has made baking cookies, toasts, and even frozen treats a breeze. I hardly ever encounter any food sticking to the sheet, which means easy cleanups, saving me a lot of time and effort.
Despite its durability claims, I have noticed some minor chipping after extended use. However, the overall construction is still quite sturdy and seems to distribute heat evenly, making it ideal for those pesky burnt bottoms.
One thing I was pleased about is that it’s not dishwasher safe as advertised, so it stays in pristine condition. However, cleaning it by hand does require a bit more elbow grease than I would prefer, but it’s worth it.
Overall, this GreenLife Cookie Sheet adds style and convenience to any baker’s kitchen. While it’s not perfect, the benefits I’ve experienced make it a worthwhile investment for someone looking to upgrade their baking tools.
Farberware Insulated Nonstick Jumbo Cookie Sheet
The Farberware Insulated Nonstick 15.5"x20" Jumbo Cookie Sheet is a versatile and durable baking accessory, perfect for baking large batches of cookies with its jumbo size and insulated features. Its double pan layers enclose an air pocket that heats and circulates throughout the baking process, ensuring even browning and beautiful results every time. The heavy-duty carbon steel construction resists warping, allowing for consistent use over time.
Top-quality nonstick coating makes cleanup a breeze and ensures that baked goods easily slide off, while the rimless pan edge simplifies handling. The Farberware Insulated Nonstick 15.5"x20" Jumbo Cookie Sheet is oven safe up to 450°F and works well with all types of cookies, ensuring that your baking adventures are enjoyable and stress-free. This nonstick cookie sheet is a great addition to any kitchen, making it an ideal gift for fellow bakers or a perfect companion for your own baking collection.
Doughmakers: Perfect for All Your Cookie Creations
Have you ever burned a batch of cookies because they stuck to the pan? Well, let me tell you about a product that solves that problem. Doughmakers’ grand cookie sheet is just what you need to get the perfect bake every time.
The first thing that stands out is the patented pebble pattern. I know, it might sound a bit strange, but it’s actually brilliant. This design not only makes the cookies slide off the sheet with ease, but it also ensures they bake evenly without needing any extra butter or oil. It’s like magic in a baking pan!
Now, let’s talk about durability. I’ve used this sheet countless times, and it still looks brand new. The commercial-grade 18 gauge aluminum ensures that it’s sturdy enough to withstand daily use without any signs of wear and tear. Plus, it’s rust-resistant, so you won’t have to worry about any nasty surprises in your baked goods.
But, there’s one downside. This sheet isn’t dishwasher safe. But hey, hand washing isn’t that big of a deal, right? Just grab a sponge and some soap, and you’ll be good to go.
Overall, the Doughmakers grand cookie sheet is a game-changer in the world of baking. The pebble pattern might seem unusual at first, but once you try it, you’ll wonder how you ever lived without it. And don’t worry about sticking or cleaning — this sheet has got you covered.
Sturdy Non-Stick Cookie Sheet with Large Capacity
As a culinary enthusiast, I’ve used my fair share of baking sheets, and let me tell you, the Cuisinart Non-Stick Baking Sheet truly shines in my kitchen. With a hefty 1.0 mm aluminized steel construction, it ensures even heating, resulting in perfectly golden brown and cooked baked goods every time. The Whitford Xylan non-stick interior and exterior make cleanup a breeze, allowing me to focus more on baking rather than the cleanup process.
The thick rolled edges add a thoughtful touch, maintaining the sheet’s structural integrity even after countless baking sessions. The 15-inch size is a game changer for those who love to bake in large quantities, making this baking sheet a must-have for both novice and experienced bakers alike.
Little Sheet Mustard Cookie Sheet
Little Sheet is a quarter-sized sheet pan perfect for smaller oven spaces, designed for baking personal portions of cookies or warming up leftovers. Made with a signature nonstick, nontoxic coating, this innovative pan is both oven-safe and dishwasher-friendly.
Available in five vibrant colors, Little Sheet adds a touch of charm to any kitchen while still being practical and easy to clean. Its compact size ensures that it doesn’t take up too much space, making it an ideal addition to any baking enthusiast’s collection.
Doughmakers Premium Biscuit Sheet for Perfect Cookies
The Doughmakers Biscuit Sheet is a professional-grade baking accessory designed to make your baked goods shine. With its commercial-grade 18 gauge aluminum construction, this sheet is perfect for creating delicious biscuits, cookies, and more. The patented pebble pattern on the surface allows for even browning and quick release, making it a healthy option for your baking needs.
The non-stick properties eliminate the need for additional oils or sprays, while its durability and rust resistance make it a reliable choice for your kitchen. Plus, its scratch-resistant performance ensures its performance won’t be affected by scratches. To maintain the sheet’s appearance, simply hand wash it promptly in hot soapy water.
GRIDMANN 15" x 21" Commercial Grade Aluminum Cookie Sheets (3 Quarter Sheets — 6 Pans)
These amazing GRIDMANN 15-inch by 21-inch aluminum baking trays are a commercial-grade stunner. They’re an ideal choice for those who love cooking large quantities of food and appreciate even heat distribution to ensure perfectly baked goodies every time.
With a 1.0mm thick rim that prevents warping and keeps the tray flat, you won’t have to worry about any unwanted surprises during your baking sessions. These trays are perfect for professional bakers and chefs who prefer aluminum pans due to their quick heating and cooling properties. Despite their sturdy build, they’re lightweight, making them easy to move around your kitchen.
And don’t worry about the material’s durability, each tray features an 18-gauge aluminum. Their galvanized wire edge further adds to their long-lasting performance and helps in maintaining the pan’s shape. The trays measure approximately 1 inch in height, 21 inches in length, and 15 inches in width, offering ample space for your baking creations.
Wilton Bake It Better Nonstick Steel Cookie Sheet (10x15 in.) — Safe for Metal Tools, Dishwasher-Safe
The Wilton Bake It Better 10" x 15" Cookie Sheet is a versatile and high-quality baking accessory that will impress your friends and family with delicious treats. Made of heavy-gauge steel, it offers large grip handles for easy transportation and use.
Its nonstick coating ensures that baked goods slide off effortlessly, without leaving any residue behind. This durable pan is also dishwasher-safe, making cleanup a breeze. The steel cookie sheet has a design that evenly distributes heat for perfect baking results.
Suitable for both inexperienced and experienced cooks, it can be used for various dishes, including cookies, cakes, and dessert bars. The steel material ensures that this cookie sheet is durable and long-lasting. Its non-stick coating and beveled edges make it a practical and easy-to-use accessory for your kitchen.
Stainless Steel Cookie Baking Sheet for Delicious Treats
This Norpro Stainless Steel Cookie Baking Sheet, also known as the #3861 S/S Cookie Baking Sheet, is just the thing for your baking needs. This 14x12 baking sheet is both versatile and multi-purpose, perfect for making cookies, pastries, biscuits, pizza, rolls, tater tots, and fries. Constructed with high quality 18/0 stainless steel, the baking sheet boasts a flat end that allows for easy sliding of your baked goods off without any mess. With a size of 14 inches/35.5cm long by 12 inches/30.5cm wide, this baking sheet offers plenty of space to work with.
However, remember that hand washing is recommended to ensure the longevity and quality of the baking sheet. User reviews have reported mixed results, with some praising its durability and ease of use, while others have encountered issues with its size and construction. Overall, the Norpro Stainless Steel Cookie Baking Sheet offers a solid and reliable option for your baking needs, but make sure to consider its size and limitations before making a purchase.
Stackable Nonstick Baking Sheet Set by JoyTable
If you’re looking for a baking sheet set that offers both quality and convenience, then the Joytable Baking Sheet Set is definitely worth considering. I found the stackability feature of these oven pans to be especially handy, as it made for easy storage in my kitchen.
One aspect of this set that I particularly appreciated was the non-stick quality. It made cleaning up a breeze after using the baking sheets, and I didn’t have to worry about my baked goods sticking to the surface. However, I did notice that the silicone handles can get hot during use, so be cautious while handling them, especially when baking.
The durability of this set also caught my attention. Despite multiple uses, my baking sheets still looked as good as new. The only downside I encountered was the occasional scratching on the surface when using metal utensils, so it’s essential to handle the baking sheets with care.
Overall, I was quite satisfied with this baking sheet set. It performed well, looked visually appealing, and made baking a more enjoyable experience. The great price point makes it an even more attractive option for those looking to upgrade their baking tools.
Perfect Results Non-Stick Cookie Sheets Set
If you’re in search of reliable baking and cookie sheets, the Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Bakeware Set offers just that. This 2-piece set, composed of high-quality, non-stick baking sheets, promises a seamless baking experience.
Ideal for both cookies and baking, these flat sheets feature slight turned-up lips for easy handling. Say goodbye to stubborn food residue — these sheets are dishwasher safe!
Perfect for both professionals and novices, these sheets are crafted with versatility in mind, offering the perfect medium for various culinary creations. The durable design ensures longevity, and the affordable pricing makes it a great replacement for older sets or even serving as a generous gift to a loved one. Users have reported high satisfaction, praising the long-lasting nature of these baking sheets and the reasonable price.
A truly essential addition to any baking enthusiast’s arsenal, the Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Bakeware Set is the perfect way to elevate your baking endeavors.
Non-Stick Cookie Sheet by Cuisinox — Perfect for Baking
The Cuisinox Non-Stick Cookie Sheet is a high-quality baking tool, perfect for whipping up your favorite cookies. Its non-stick coating ensures that your treats slide off effortlessly after baking, all while being easy to clean up. Made from durable materials and available in a reasonably priced option, this cookie sheet not only looks great but also provides a reliable performance.
Some users have reported minor issues with dented products, while others have faced difficulties removing the non-stick coating. However, many satisfied customers have praised the sturdiness and durability of this cookie sheet. Overall, it’s a solid choice for anyone looking to enhance their cookie-baking experience without breaking the bank.
Farberware Nonstick Cookie Sheet Set
As a lover of baked goods, I’ve had the pleasure of using the Farberware Nonstick 3-Piece Cookie Pan Set, Grey. In my experience, it has made a significant difference in the quality of my cookies and other baked treats.
The heavy-duty construction of this cookie pan set truly stands out. It resists warping and heats evenly, ensuring that my baked goods come out looking and tasting incredible, with beautifully browned edges. This feature is especially important for reducing hot spots that can sometimes burn baked goods.
The nonstick coating inside and out is a game-changer for quick and easy clean-up. No more struggling with stubborn cookie dough or burnt-on messes — this set makes the clean-up process a breeze.
However, I have noticed that the pans are a bit smaller than I expected, which might not be ideal for larger batches of cookies. Additionally, the grey color can be a bit tricky to clean after use, as it sometimes shows noticeable stains.
Overall, the Farberware Nonstick 3-Piece Cookie Pan Set, Grey is a fantastic addition to any kitchen, offering excellent performance and convenient features. Despite the minor drawbacks, the pros definitely outweigh the cons, making this a worthwhile investment for any baker.
Lekue Non-Spill Baking Sheet — Perfect for Cookies and Goodies
As an avid lover of nutritious and effortless culinary pursuits, discovering the Lekue non-spill baking sheet was indeed a game-changer. Incorporating it into my meal planning routine has proven to be a boon, with its efficiency shining through in various recipes.
One standout element of this baking sheet is its compatibility with standard-sized trays. During hectic times, this feature comes in handy, allowing me to eliminate the tedious process of reshaping trays to accommodate the sheet.
The spill-proof capability of this baking sheet transformed my baking experience. No longer did I need to deal with the grunt work of cleaning up after messy spills in my oven. The non-stick surface, constructed from top-notch silicone, proved to be the perfect solution for preventing food from latching onto the sheet. Consequently, cleanup became a breeze.
Although the baking sheet possesses commendable spill-proofing capabilities, its flexibility left something to be desired. This downside surfaced notably when attempting to transfer it from the oven to the counter, where it almost bent in half. To avoid potential accidents, extra caution during the transfer process was essential.
Reflecting on my experience, the Lekue non-spill baking sheet serves as an indispensable asset in any kitchen. Its ease of use and efficient cleanup process make it a top pick for those craving a hassle-free and healthy baking solution.
Stainless Steel Cookie Sheet with Cooling Rack for Even Baking and Easy Cleanup
I’ve been using the TeamFar Baking Sheet with Rack Set for a few weeks now, and I must say, it’s made quite an impression on me. The stainless steel tray and rack are both strong and durable, proving to be the perfect addition to my daily baking routine.
What I appreciate the most about this baking sheet is its non-toxic nature. Made of high-quality stainless steel without any toxic chemical coatings, it’s safe for me and my family to use, even on a daily basis. And the fact that it doesn’t rust is a nice bonus!
The overall aesthetic of the baking sheet is pleasing too. The smooth, shiny finish and the carefully designed lines on the rack make for an exquisite craftsmanship that I’m quite proud to display in my kitchen.
What’s more? The easy-clean feature of this baking sheet is a life-saver. With deep full sides that prevent sauces from flowing everywhere, and both the sheet and rack being dishwasher safe, cleanup is a breeze.
Now, let’s talk about the even cooking aspect. The rack fits perfectly inside the baking pan, lifting the food above the juice to allow hot air to circulate, ensuring a more evenly baked product. The cooling rack can also be removed from the sheet for cooling purposes — a feature I find incredibly handy.
And, not to forget, this baking sheet with rack set is versatile. Its dimensions are ideal for a wide variety of baking or roasting needs. I’ve used it for everything from baking and cooling bacon to roasting vegetables, chicken wings, ribs, and even cookies. It definitely does not disappoint.
In conclusion, my experience with this baking sheet has been entirely positive. Its non-toxic material, exquisite craftsmanship, easy clean feature, even cooking capacity, and multi-use nature make it a worthy addition to my kitchen. Highly recommended!
Buyer’s Guide
A cookie sheet is a versatile kitchen tool that can be used for more than just baking cookies. It can help you cook a variety of delicious meals, from roasted vegetables and pastries to casseroles and even candy. With so many options available, it’s essential to understand the features and considerations before making a purchase to ensure you get the best cookie sheet for your needs.
Materials
Cookie sheets come in various materials, such as aluminum, stainless steel, and silicone. Aluminum sheets are lightweight and inexpensive, but they may warp over time. Stainless steel sheets are more durable and resistant to warping, but they can be heavier and more expensive. Silicone sheets are non-stick and flexible, making them a popular choice for baking, but they might not be suitable for high-heat cooking.
Size
Another essential factor to consider when choosing a cookie sheet is size. Sheets come in various sizes, from small 9-inch round sheets to large half-sheet or full-sheet options. Consider the size you typically need for the recipes you plan to make. If you often bake bread, a full-sheet option might be the best choice. However, for smaller batches or those with limited storage space, a half-sheet or smaller size is more suitable.
Coating
Cookie sheets may also come with a non-stick coating. This can make it easier to clean and reduce the amount of oil or butter required when cooking. Non-stick coatings can vary in quality, so look for one that is durable and long-lasting. Some non-stick coatings may also include materials like silicone or ceramic, which can offer better heat distribution and reduce the risk of scorching.
Shape
Cookie sheets come in different shapes, such as round, rectangular, and even heart-shaped. The shape you choose will depend on the type of food you plan to cook and the size of your oven. Round sheets are ideal for single batch cookies or biscuits, while rectangular sheets are more versatile and can accommodate multiple cookies or other baked goods. Heart-shaped sheets can be fun for special occasions like Valentine’s Day baking.
FAQ
What are the benefits of using a high-quality cookie sheet?
A high-quality cookie sheet offers several benefits, such as even heat distribution, which ensures consistent baking results. The non-stick surface prevents cookies from sticking to the sheet, making cleanup easier. Additionally, many high-quality cookie sheets are made from durable materials that can withstand high temperatures, making them safer to use.
Moreover, a good quality cookie sheet often comes with features like textured surfaces or ridged edges, which help promote airflow around the cookies, resulting in a crispy exterior while keeping the interior soft and chewy. These features make it easier to achieve restaurant-quality cookies at home.
What is the difference between a dark and light-colored cookie sheet?
The main difference between a dark and light-colored cookie sheet lies in how they absorb and distribute heat. Light-colored cookie sheets tend to reflect more heat, which in turn allows the bottom of the cookies to cook more evenly. This can prevent bottoms from becoming overcooked while the tops are still baking.
On the other hand, dark-colored cookie sheets absorb more heat. While this can help promote a beautiful golden brown color on the tops of cookies, it can also lead to uneven baking if not managed properly. Cookies placed on a darker sheet will tend to brown faster, so it is essential to use a lower temperature and adjust baking times accordingly.
What materials are used to make cookie sheets today?
Today, cookie sheets are typically made from materials like aluminum, stainless steel, or even silicone. Aluminum is lightweight and an excellent heat conductor, making it a popular choice for many cookie sheets. However, aluminum cookie sheets can warp under high heat, which might affect baking results. To mitigate this issue, some manufacturers now combine aluminum with other materials, such as stainless steel.
Stainless steel cookie sheets are durable and resistant to warping, which makes them a preferred choice for commercial use. They also do not react with baking ingredients, offering peace of mind when cooking with sensitive recipes. However, stainless steel can be a little more expensive than other materials.
How should I clean a cookie sheet after use?
After use, it is essential to clean the cookie sheet properly to maintain its non-stick surface and for health purposes. Most cookie sheets can be cleaned by hand using warm soapy water and a soft sponge or dishcloth. Avoid using abrasive cleaning agents or metal scouring pads, as they can damage the non-stick surface.
If your cookie sheet has built-up grease or burnt bits, you can try soaking it in warm soapy water for a while before scrubbing gently. Alternatively, you can also use a baking soda and water paste to scrub away stubborn stains. After cleaning, make sure to dry the cookie sheet thoroughly before storing it to prevent rust.
Are there any special care instructions for storing a cookie sheet?
It is essential to dry a cookie sheet thoroughly after cleaning to prevent rust. If you notice water spots or condensation, simply pat the sheet dry with a soft cloth or place it in an open area to air dry completely. Store the cookie sheet in a dry, cool place away from direct sunlight to prevent discoloration and damage to the non-stick surface.
If you have a two-sided cookie sheet, it is best to store it with the non-stick side facing outward to prevent scratches and maintain the non-stick surface. It is also advisable to stack cookie sheets together with a piece of parchment or wax paper in between to prevent them from sticking to each other.
How do I know if my cookie sheet has lost its non-stick properties?
If your non-stick cookie sheet has started to lose its non-stick properties, it may be time to replace it. Signs that your cookie sheet has lost its non-stick capabilities include food sticking to the sheet, requiring more oil or grease during baking, or having visible scratches and wear on the surface.
In such cases, it is best to invest in a new non-stick cookie sheet to ensure consistent baking results and prolong the longevity of your baking equipment. If you prefer, you can also try seasoning the cookie sheet with oil to regain its non-stick properties. However, the effectiveness of this method may vary depending on the material of the cookie sheet and the extent of damage.
As an Amazon Affiliate™, I earn through qualifying purchases at no cost to you!
